• St. Albans Sanitorium

    Whats Your Theory is back! We're here to kick off spooky season with a bit of a new format and expanded team. Jared tells us the story of St Albans Sanitorium and teases some true crime to look forward to in the future.

    1h 25m - Oct 6, 2022
  • The Grafton Monster

    We stay in West Virginia this week to tell the story of the Grafton Monster. Through all the twists and turns in his story was Robert Cockrell telling the truth? Witness the first time Jared and I disagree on a conclusion this time on What's Your Theory!

    1h 6m - Aug 15, 2022
  • The Hauntings of theTrans-Allegheny Lunatic Asylum

    Jared and Will explore an asylum in West Virginia that is known to be one of the most haunted places in appalachia. Will gives us the history and recounts some tales from the building. The two even share what could perhaps be their own personal piece of paranormal evidence.

    Here are some links if you want to donate to the flood relief programs.




    1h 6m - Aug 8, 2022
  • What Your Dreams Mean

    Jared and Will hop into dreamworld today as Will regales Jared with his terrifying dreams.

    54m - Jul 27, 2022
  • Alien Gunfight in Kentucky

    Join Jared and Will on a crazy story today as we journey back to Kentucky to talk about more aliens. This time though things take a violent turn in what can only be described as a truly Kentuckian reaction.

    1h 8m - Jul 18, 2022
  • The Banshee

    Join Jared and Will as we are guided through many tales of the notorious banshee. Be prepared for accents even more scary than the tales on this episode of Whats Your Theory.

    1h 2m - Jul 11, 2022
  • Alien Abduction In Kentucky

    Today Will tells the tale of three women from Kentucky who may have experienced an alien abduction. Join us today on What's Your Theory

    58m - Jul 4, 2022
  • The Old House Woods

    Jared and Will explore the Chesapeake bay's oldest ghost tales on todays episode of "What's Your Theory?"

    We take a look at a patch of woods that has centuries worth of spooky tales and strange occurrences. We then offer our theories as to what could be the cause of such a long lasting haunt.

    Make sure to rate and follow for more and follow us on our other social platforms!


    1h 1m - Jun 20, 2022
  • Bobby Mackey's Music World

    Jared and Will dive into the tale of Bobby Mackey and his haunted bar in Wilder Kentucky. Join us as we uncover the secrets of one of the most haunted bars in the country

    1h 2m - Jun 13, 2022
  • The Bell Witch

    Jared and Will take a short journey to Adam's Tennessee to discuss the tale of the Bell Witch. A tale that involves an entity terrorizing a family in the early 1800's. American president Andrew Jackson even reportedly investigated the haunting. Please Rate if you enjoy this episode of What's Your Theory.

    1h 8m - Jun 6, 2022
  • Appalachian Trail Mysteries

    A trail that spans over 2,000 miles and takes more than half a year must have many mysteries... right? Jared and Will look into the Appalachian Trail and explore both the supernatural and very real mysteries of one of the longest hiking trails in the world. The Appalachian Trail

    1h 7m - May 30, 2022
  • The Vegetable Man of West Virginia

    Jared and Will are back with a new episode of Whats Your Theory. This episode they are taking a look at the Vegetable man of West Virginia. A story of a West Virginia man's encounter with a possible extraterrestrial.

    E13 - 1h 4m - May 24, 2022
  • Blue People in Kentucky

    Jared and I are back after taking a short hiatus to take care of some business. Join us on this episode as we talk about The Fugate Family. This family was born in Kentucky with blue skin. Learn a little bit about genetics on this informational edition of What's Your Theory

    E12 - 1h 2m - May 16, 2022
  • The Haint & The Hidebehind

    Join Jared and Will as they explore two Appalachian legends. Wait for the end to hear a big announcement

    E11 - 52m - Apr 10, 2022
  • Feral People

    Are there people that are more animal than man that live in the National Parks? Does the government try to cover up their existence? Jared and Will explore the idea of Feral people today on Whats Your Theory?

    Check out our other pages




    E10 - 44m - Mar 31, 2022
  • Missing 411: Disappearances in National Parks

    Is there a sinister pattern to disappearances in The United States National Parks? Is the Government aware of the cause to these cases? Will Jared and Will ever go to a national park again? Find out that and more on todays episode of What's Your Theory?

    E9 - 1h 28m - Mar 24, 2022
  • Skinwalkers

    Join Jared and Will as they discuss the terrifying Navajo legend of The Skinwalker. We give a description and read some first hand accounts and eventually ask Whats Your Theory?

    E8 - 1h 8m - Mar 15, 2022
  • Appalachian Ghost Stories: The Fingerbone

    Jared and Will discuss more stories from Se Shlosser's book "Spooky Virginia". These tales include "The Convert" and "The Fingerbone".

    We then read some ghost stories from our hometown.

    E7 - 1h 18m - Mar 6, 2022
  • Appalachian Vampire: Rupp

    Was there a vampire named Rupp that stalked his prey in Big Stone Gap Va. Did he dismember and eat the cattle in the area. Find out all that and more on this episode of Whats Your Theory!

    Twitter: https://twitter.com/whats_ur_theory?t=KarUMjbsEt34FqgtqnuABQ&s=09


    E6 - 1h 16m - Feb 28, 2022
  • Creepypastas: The Rake

    Is there a creature that has a sole purpose to drive you to suicide or is that completely preposterous. We are going to explore that and more on today’s episode of What’s Your Theory?

    E5 - 1h 20m - Feb 19, 2022
Audio Player Image
What's Your Theory?