SHOW / EPISODE

Andrea Yates Said Satan Told Her To Do It

5m | Oct 12, 2026

On the morning of June 20, 2001, Andrea Yates filled a bathtub in her Houston home and drowned all five of her children. Noah was seven. John was five. Paul was three. Luke was two. Mary was six months old. When she was done, she called the police and waited.

Yates had been hospitalised multiple times in the two years before the killings. She had attempted suicide twice. She had told her psychiatrist she was having visions. She believed Satan had taken up residence inside her body, that she was the worst mother in history, and that the only way to save her children from hell was to kill them before they could sin further. By her own account, she had been fighting the voice for months.

Her first trial produced a murder conviction that was later overturned — a prosecution expert had fabricated testimony about a Law and Order episode that didn’t exist. Her second trial produced a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity. She has been in a state psychiatric facility ever since. The case fundamentally changed how American courts, medical professionals, and the public understand postpartum psychosis. This episode covers the full story — the illness, the killings, both trials, and the question the case still leaves open: where does mental illness end and criminal responsibility begin?

Subscribe to The 5-Minute Strange — true stories that refuse to be simple. Available everywhere you listen to podcasts.

#AndreaYates #TrueCrime #TrueCrimeAustralia #PostpartumPsychosis #CriminalJustice #AndreaYatesCase #5MinutePodcast #MentalHealthAwareness #TheFiveMinuteStrange #TrueCrimePodcast #PodcastAustralia #StrangeStories #NotGuiltyByReasonOfInsanity #CrimePodcast #TrueStories

Paused
Audio Player Image
5 Minute Strange - True Stories You Never Knew
Loading...